John Mack Newtown

Newtown Township's 2027 Preliminary Budget: Tax Increases, Spending Priorities and Unanswered Questions

Summary of the November 16, 2026 Board of Supervisors Budget Work Session

With only three supervisors present (Kyle Davis, Ed Merriman, Melissa Merk), the Newtown Township Board of Supervisors (BOS) discussed a proposed 2027 budget featuring essentially flat services and revenue but rising costs, particularly for police and fire protection.

The draft reflects an approximately 16% increase in the property-tax portion discussed at the meeting, with budget figures moving from the $17 million range to the $19 million range. Residents urged supervisors to demonstrate meaningful cuts to discretionary spending before asking taxpayers to pay more.

The following video was create via Zoom during the meeting. No official video was created by the township.

You can also listen to this 18-minute “Deep Dive” podcast:

Mack's Newtown Voice · #NewtownPA 2027 Budget Deep Dive

1. The Budget Picture

~16%Draft property-tax increase cited at the meeting
48%General fund share attributed to police
~$400KBudgeted borough fire contribution
Dec. 9Earliest possible 2027 budget adoption
  • Flat service levels: Board Chair Ed Merriman described township services and workload as essentially unchanged from 2026, while fuel, insurance, pensions and fire equipment costs continue to rise.
  • Police costs: Police account for approximately 48% of the general fund, within the 45–55% range cited during the discussion.
  • Fire equipment: The fire fleet includes trucks dating to 2001, 2008 and 2010. New apparatus has already been ordered and incorporated into the budget.
  • Volunteer decline: Active fire volunteers reportedly declined from roughly 35–50 three decades ago to about 10–15 today, increasing reliance on paid firefighters. A two-year grant that previously subsidized firefighter salaries is expiring, creating a severe revenue shortfall—specifically a $1 million grant loss expiring in March, as highlighted by resident Charles Feuer. This decline in civic volunteerism directly converts what was historically a free community service into a mandatory, permanent municipal payroll obligation.
  • Grant expiration: A grant that helped cover additional firefighter costs for two years has expired, creating a revenue gap.
  • Financial buffer: Merriman said the 2021 tax increase established a cushion that is now being depleted by rising expenses and flat revenues. Under current projections with zero changes to baseline revenue, township reserve buffers will hit absolute zero in 2029, proving that relying on past rainy-day balances is mathematically unsustainable.

  • Tax allocation: A supervisor emphasized that the proposed increase is for police and fire rather than the general fund.

Police Share of the General Fund

Supervisor Melissa Merk described Newtown's tax burden as roughly middle-of-the-pack among comparable townships. She favored reducing discretionary spending, while emphasizing that needed police vehicles are non-negotiable. 

"Yes, there's a 15% increase in your township taxes which is only about 10 cents of every dollar of your property taxes,” Said Merk. “So I don't want that 15% number to get blown up as the irresponsible or huge..."

2. Resident Comments: Must-Haves Versus Nice-to-Haves

Eric Pomerantz: Budget Priorities and Revenue Accuracy

Resident Eric Pomerantz urged supervisors to distinguish essential expenses — police, fire, fair compensation, medical benefits and police vehicles — from discretionary spending. He argued that visible cuts would help establish the legitimacy of a tax increase.

  • Questioned whether the Borough's fire contribution and Wrightstown's police payments represent fair shares of service costs.
  • Noted zero amounts for state and federal grants in the draft budget and raised concerns about the vacant zoning/code enforcement position and potential lost revenue.
  • Questioned approximately $125,000 in third-party technology services on budget page B6 and whether some work could be performed internally. A township official responded that backup, security and subscription services cannot be performed in-house.
  • Flagged a discrepancy of $100,000 or more between the 2026 projected police pension expense and the lower 2027 budget figure. Merriman indicated there was a reason and said the township could follow up, but no explanation was provided during the meeting.
  • Asked whether the 2026 road construction program would be completed by year-end.
  • Challenged the use of conservative revenue projections when calculating the tax increase. Merriman said actual revenues historically tend to exceed budget estimates.
Unanswered: Why is the 2027 police pension budget substantially lower than the 2026 projected expenditure?

Charles Feuer: Long-Term Planning and Grants

  • Recommended a multi-year equipment replacement plan, including a schedule for replacing approximately two police vehicles annually and established fire apparatus replacement cycles.
  • Called for an independent accounting review of the Wrightstown police contract to confirm the payments adequately cover township costs.
  • Requested a grant application schedule, noting that opportunities such as PennDOT funding could offset local costs.
  • Asked who currently performs zoning and code enforcement. Merk said a third-party provider performs code enforcement and generates inspection revenue, while the township intends to pursue an in-house hire.

The source document calls for an ISEO table here but does not provide the figures. Insert the verified table before publishing.

John Mack: Salaries, Road Maintenance and Public Transparency

  • Road selection: Mack criticized the lack of a publicly available list of roads selected for paving, describing the selection process as a black box. Merk said the list originates with Public Works.
  • Road monitoring: Merk mentioned a contractor's proposal for AI-powered pavement-condition monitoring using public works vehicles, which she had not yet reviewed.
  • Management compensation: Mack presented data showing management salaries increasing by an average of 9.4% compared to a 3.2% Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) for support staff, alongside a 194.2% jump in total Code Enforcement salary allocations ($125K in 2026 to $368K proposed in 2027). Supervisor Merk counter-balanced this figure, explaining that the township is restructuring the department by bringing code enforcement oversight in-house via a director position while capturing substantial offsetting third-party inspection revenues.

  • Road funding: The budget allocates ~$850,000 for road repaving (covering ~2.5 to 2.6 miles at $330,000 per mile). Mack noted this falls far short of the 3.5 miles required annually just to maintain current road quality. Addressing this gap, Supervisor Merk referenced an active pitch from engineering firm Remington & Vernick for AI-powered road-condition sensors mounted on public works vehicles to continuously map pavement degradation and prioritize repairs systematically.

  • Business donations: Mack proposed seeking contributions from local businesses for public amenities, including the Roberts Ridge Park playground replacement. The proposed budget includes $330,000 allocated to Roberts Ridge Park – presumably to install a new up-to-cade playground.
  • Clark Nature Center: Mack expressed hope that spending here would result in a safe reopening, since programs hosted there has stopped.

The Road Funding Gap

Measure Approximate Amount
2027 road funding discussed $850,000
Estimated resurfacing cost per mile $330,000
Miles fundable at that rate 2.5–2.6 miles
Annual mileage needed to maintain conditions 3.5 miles
Approximate annual shortfall 0.9–1.0 mile

Bottom line: Based on the estimates cited at the meeting, the proposed road allocation falls short of the annual paving mileage needed to maintain current road conditions. Mack asked whether money allocated to “nice to have” projects in specific funds – such as the Recreational Capital Fund – could be redirected to “need to have” road repaving. No answer was provided.

3. Borough Fire Agreement and Wrightstown Police Contract

Supervisor Merk explained that the Borough's proposed fire-service contribution was calculated using population, parcels, assessed property values and emergency call volume. Newtown Township provides fire coverage to neighboring Newtown Borough under a fair-share agreement set at 11.4% of budgeted expenses ($400,000), escalating at 5% annually under a three-year contract with a 180-day exit clause.

This contract represents a massive structural jump from the $175,000 baseline Newtown Borough previously paid for fire service. Widespread public confusion and intermunicipal friction erupted when initial public estimates claimed the Borough would owe upwards of $500,000 (a 15% share). Supervisor Melissa Merk, a former accountant, audited the raw spreadsheet cells behind the formula and discovered a simple cell link error:

"There was an error in one of the cells that made that calculation just be wrong... It made it look like it was 15% instead of 11%... I do remember how to use Excel. And so I went into the individual cells and looked at them and just saw that there was that error there..."

The $100,000 discrepancy underscores the incredible vulnerability of multi-million-dollar public contracts to human spreadsheet errors, highlighting the absolute necessity of rigorous internal financial audits.

Fire Agreement Item Reported Terms
Borough contribution 11.4% of budgeted expenses
2027 budget figure Approximately $400,000
Previous Borough payment Approximately $175,000*
Contract term 3 years, with optional 2-year extension
Annual escalator 5%
Withdrawal provision 180 days' notice, as described by Merk
Borough approval Not yet completed as of November 16

*As mentioned above, Merk said an earlier estimate approaching $500,000 resulted from an Excel error that incorrectly calculated the Borough's share at approximately 15% rather than 11%. She said the corrected methodologies supported a figure near $400,000.

Regarding Wrightstown, Merk said she had not yet reviewed the police agreement but understood it included an annual escalator and intended to examine it in the coming months.

4. Grants, Savings and Alternative Funding

  • Grant assistance: Merk described an offer of grant-application assistance from a consultant contact, but said the township had not pursued it further. She wants to discuss the opportunity with the Township Manager.
  • Playground sponsorships: Mack volunteered to approach businesses about donations and said he planned to raise the issue with Jim Worthington at an upcoming lunch.
  • Board response: Supervisors indicated they would welcome donations secured for playground improvements.
  • Discretionary reductions: Residents encouraged the Board to review smaller discretionary items as well as major expenses before finalizing the budget.

5. Budget Adoption Timeline

November 16, 2026 — Budget Work Session

Supervisors discussed the draft budget and received resident questions and recommendations.

November 24, 2026 — Scheduled BOS Meeting

The budget cannot be adopted at this meeting because the required 20-day advertisement period has not elapsed.

December 9, 2026 — Earliest Possible Adoption

The Board may vote on the budget if applicable notice requirements are satisfied.

The discussion also noted that an overall revenue increase exceeding 10% above the advertised amount would trigger a new advertisement period, while reductions to individual line items could be made without re-advertising.

6. Questions Still Needing Answers

Issue Outstanding Question or Follow-Up
Police pension Explain the difference between the 2026 projection and 2027 budget figure.
Discretionary spending Identify reductions before the budget adoption vote.
Wrightstown police contract Review reimbursement terms and annual escalator.
Grant funding Discuss outside grant assistance and opportunities.
Road maintenance Clarify road-selection transparency and review the AI monitoring proposal.
Playground funding Explore private-business donations for park improvements.
Salary transparency Clarify management compensation and grouped salary line items.
Fund transfers Determine whether funds can be redirected to higher-priority needs.

7. The Bottom Line

The central debate at the November 16 work session was not whether police, fire and other essential services cost more. It was whether the township has done enough to distinguish unavoidable expenses from discretionary spending and to ensure that revenue projections, contract contributions and budget assumptions are accurate.

Before the December 9 adoption opportunity, residents are looking for clear answers about pension costs, management salaries, road funding, outside contracts and possible savings — along with evidence that supervisors have carefully examined alternatives to higher taxes.

Based on the supplied summary of the November 16, 2026 Newtown Township preliminary budget work session. Financial amounts and statements are attributed to the meeting summary and should not be interpreted as independently audited figures.