Recap of the 18 November 2025 Planning Commission Meeting
Observations from the Newtown Township Planning Commission meeting held on November 18, 2025.
To many people, a local planning commission meeting sounds like the definition of tedium—a dry, procedural exercise in zoning ordinances and setback requirements. The common perception is that these gatherings are best left to municipal officials and directly affected property owners, offering little of interest to the wider business community.
In reality, these meetings are often fascinating, real-time case studies in the friction between community rules, business needs, and the pressures of modern life. They offer a tactical roadmap for how businesses can successfully navigate local bureaucracy—or fail spectacularly. By observing the Newtown Township Planning Commission's November 18, 2025 meeting, I uncovered several surprising and counter-intuitive lessons for any business owner.
Listen to this 13-minute “Deep Dive” podcast summery:
Here are the four most impactful takeaways from a single evening of local governance, showing that a successful appeal is about much more than just having a good idea.
1. The Perils of Asking for Forgiveness, Not Permission
North Sycamore Street.
The case of Mélange on Sycamore restaurant began with an aesthetic proposition. The business sought approval for nine large, etched-glass window signs, each featuring a sycamore tree—a significant variance from the two signs permitted by the ordinance.
The critical detail, however, was that these unapproved signs—along with other unauthorized modifications to a historic building—had already been installed before proper approvals were sought. The business's new representatives attributed this to a previous contractor, but the fact remained: they proceeded without permission and were now seeking retroactive approval.
The commission's reaction focused less on the artistic merit of the signs and more on the procedural violation. Members noted that the unapproved work had defaced a historic building. The business argued that the new signs were beautiful and that "the public actually likes it this way better," but the commission viewed this as a self-created hardship, not a valid reason for a variance.
This smelled a lot like: we'll try to get forgiveness rather than permission.
The commission's frustration was compounded by the fact that the business broke the rules for something that lacked practical business function. As several members pointed out, the purely decorative signs failed as actual advertisements. They were beautiful, but useless.
“There's nothing about these signs that say restaurant in here… These signs just say there's trees in the window.”
“I don't see how it would attract business.”
That turns the lesson from simply “don't break the rules” into the more potent: “don't incur massive risk for a violation that doesn't even serve a core business purpose.”
2. Does First Trust Bank Really Need a Sign on Durham Road?
First Trust Bank presented what would seem like a standard request. Having operated at their location for 18 years, they wanted to install a new monument sign, which required variances for its size, height, and location within a public right-of-way. Their reasoning was straightforward: the existing building sign was obscured by trees, and they wanted to increase visibility for “pass-through traffic.”
The commission’s response, however, was surprisingly modern and counter-intuitive. Members questioned the fundamental need for a physical sign in the digital age. They argued that customers now use phones and GPS to find businesses, making a new monument sign for an established bank a questionable expense with little real-world impact.
“I kind of have a hard time believing that a sign is going to help generate additional customers or revenue for a bank, especially if they've been there for 18 years. There’s really more of a shift towards using Google search engine optimization and digital ads…”
Beyond digital disruption, the commission and a commenting resident raised a second, crucial objection: the negative cumulative impact of sign pollution on the town's character. Approving one sign could set a precedent, creating a “domino effect” of new signs along the road.
“If you give them a sign,” resident John Mack said, “maybe Santander Bank would want a sign… Imagine having all these bank signs along that road. It's ridiculous.”
Mack also noted that the township cited the Brixmor shopping senter for an illegal billboard along Durham Rd. For more read “Brixmor's Illegal Billboard Sign Removed.”
The insight here: the commission isn't just evaluating a request in a vacuum, but its potential to alter the community's aesthetic and set long-term precedent.
3. The “Goldilocks” Request: A Modest Ask with a Clear Need
In stark contrast to the bank’s difficult hearing, the application from an office park at 826–828 Newtown-Yardley Road demonstrated the power of a reasonable, well-justified request. The property owner asked to replace two existing signs with two new ones that were modestly larger than the ordinance allowed (40 sq. ft. requested vs. 32 sq. ft. permitted), in order to better display the names of their eight tenants.
Their justification was compelling: the office park was struggling to retain tenants, the curved road made wayfinding difficult, and tenants such as a pediatrician and a physical rehab clinic rely on clear signage for new clients who may be unfamiliar with the location.
The commission’s reaction was immediate and positive. They viewed the request as a minimal variance (de minimis) that addressed a genuine business hardship. One member even noted that signs that are too small can themselves be a hazard.
“I think the relief is de minimis. I mean, in order to keep tenants, people got to know where they're going… I can finally see where 826 is.”
This request succeeded where others failed because it was a modest ask tied directly to a clear and understandable business need. It presented a professional, well-reasoned case that the commission could easily support.
4. The Counter-Intuitive Win: How Growing Your Business Can Fix Your Parking Problem
The final case of the night, from the restaurant Vecchia Osteria, offered a surprisingly simple path to approval: strategic growth. The restaurant proposed to lease an adjacent 500 sq. ft. space to add 24 seats for private events. Typically, adding seats would trigger a need for more parking, potentially creating a new zoning problem.
But in this case, the expansion actually reduced the restaurant’s pre-existing parking deficiency. The newly leased space came with 19 dedicated parking spots. That was more than enough to cover the requirement for the 24 new seats and, in doing so, improved the restaurant's overall compliance with the township's parking ordinances.
The commission also noted that most surrounding businesses in the shopping center are closed during the restaurant's peak evening hours, further mitigating any potential parking issues.
This case shows that smart expansion can sometimes be the easiest route to zoning approval—especially when it provides an elegant solution to an existing non-conformity.
The Devil (and the Approval) Is in the Details
The outcomes of this single meeting reveal a clear playbook for local zoning appeals. Success is not determined by aesthetics or tradition, but by a well-prepared case that demonstrates a tangible business hardship while respecting established processes. :contentReference[oaicite:10]{index=10}
From a restaurant's costly unforced error to a bank's failure to justify its impact on community character, the message is clear: the most persuasive argument is one built on reason, necessity, and a detailed understanding of the rules.
As our towns navigate the line between preserving community character and fostering economic growth, these small-scale decisions offer a revealing look at the future of local business in Newtown Township.
What do you think? Should local boards be tougher, looser, or “Goldilocks just right” when it comes to granting variances for signs, parking, and business expansion? Share your thoughts here...
Connect With Us